PGPony vs iPGMail.
iPGMail has been a quiet workhorse on iOS since 2011 — paid, focused, actively maintained by Wyllys Ingersoll. PGPony is the newer entrant: free, cross-platform, with a modern UI and OpenPGP v6 import support. Both implement the same standard. The differences are in approach.
Want a one-time-paid, established iOS app from an independent developer with a long track record? iPGMail. Want free, cross-platform (iOS + Android), modern UI, OpenPGP v6 import, and active feature development? PGPony.
At a glance.
| PGPony | iPGMail | |
|---|---|---|
| Platforms | iOS 17.6+, Android 8.0+ | iOS only |
| Price | Free | $2.99 one-time |
| License | Proprietary | Proprietary |
| First released | 2025 | 2011 |
| Active development | Yes — regular releases | Yes — regular releases |
| Key generation | Ed25519 + Cv25519 (default), RSA | RSA, ECDSA, EdDSA, ECDH |
| OpenPGP v4 (RFC 4880) | Full | Full |
| OpenPGP ECC (RFC 6637) | Full | Full |
| OpenPGP v6 (RFC 9580) | Import, decrypt, verify (gen in v6.0) | Not yet |
| QR key exchange | Yes | No |
| WKD lookup | Yes | No (keyserver search only) |
| Biometric unlock | Face ID / Touch ID | Face ID / Touch ID |
| iCloud Keychain sync | Yes | Files-based, not Keychain |
| iOS Mail.app share extension | Yes | Yes |
| Localizations | 6 languages | English primarily |
| UI generation | iOS 17.6+ native SwiftUI | Long-evolved UIKit interface |
Honest tradeoffs.
Where iPGMail wins
- Track record. iPGMail has been on the App Store continuously since 2011. That\'s 14+ years of bug fixes, iOS-version transitions, and user feedback baked into the product. PGPony is much younger.
- One-time purchase model. Pay $2.99 once, own it. Some users actively prefer this over "free" — it\'s a clear vendor-customer relationship without monetization concerns down the road.
- Direct support relationship. Wyllys Ingersoll is the long-standing developer; users can reach him via the iPGMail support address with response history dating back over a decade.
- Wider legacy key-type support. iPGMail handles DSA keys (older but still encountered in long-running PGP setups) alongside RSA and ECC. PGPony supports DSA for interop too, but iPGMail\'s older-key handling has been battle-tested longer.
- Familiar workflow for long-time PGP users. If you\'ve been doing PGP on iOS since the early days, iPGMail\'s information architecture is what you\'re used to.
Where PGPony wins
- Free. Self-explanatory. No barrier to install and try.
- Android too. iPGMail is iOS only — if you also have an Android device, or anyone in your contact list does, PGPony covers both with the same identity.
- OpenPGP v6 (RFC 9580) import support. PGPony reads v6 keys, decrypts v6 messages, and verifies v6 signatures today. iPGMail has not announced v6 support.
- QR code key exchange. Hand someone your public key by scanning. Useful at meetups, conferences, in-person handoffs. iPGMail does not have this.
- WKD lookup. Web Key Directory lookups happen automatically when you type a recipient\'s email — domain-published keys appear without manual import. iPGMail relies on keyserver search instead.
- Modern SwiftUI interface. Built for iOS 17.6+ with native Swift / SwiftUI patterns — animations, dynamic type, accessibility, dark mode all using current iOS conventions.
- Six-language localization. English, German, Spanish, French, Japanese, Brazilian Portuguese. iPGMail is primarily English.
- iCloud Keychain key sync between iOS devices. PGPony syncs keys via iCloud Keychain (Apple\'s end-to-end encrypted store), so iPad and iPhone share keys automatically. iPGMail uses file-based key transfer.
Moving between them.
Both apps produce standard OpenPGP ASCII-armored output, so moving a key (or running both side-by-side) is straightforward:
- In the source app, find Export / Backup for your key. Both apps offer "ASCII armored" output.
- Save the resulting
.ascfile to the Files app. - In the destination app, open Files and import the same
.asc. Both apps recognize standard OpenPGP key blocks. - Same fingerprint, same UIDs, same subkey structure. You can keep both apps in parallel if you want a backup, or delete from the source after confirming.
The verdict.
- Choose iPGMail if You\'re iOS-only, you prefer the one-time-paid model from an established independent developer, and the long-running track record matters to you. iPGMail\'s 14+ years on the App Store is a real signal of stability.
- Choose PGPony if You want free. Or cross-platform (iOS + Android with the same identity). Or modern OpenPGP v6 import support. Or QR key exchange. Or WKD lookup. Or a SwiftUI-native iOS 17.6+ interface. Or localization in any of six languages.
- Try both Both apps are independent of each other and use the same standard. Try PGPony free first; if you prefer iPGMail\'s feel, the $2.99 is modest. Either way, your key is portable.
Try PGPony
Free. No accounts. No tracking. Works with everything that speaks OpenPGP.